PHP open-source shopping carts: OpenCart and Magento
written by Craig, 13 November 2007
I’ve been evaluating both of these shopping cart systems for a project I’m working on. Here are my opinions after a few hours testing…
OpenCart (v0.7.7 tested)
OpenCart looks great and is simple to setup and use. It’s probably aimed at smaller online shops, but is stable, fast, and caches pages. It’s new, so there aren’t many mods or themes just yet. Custom templates look straight-forward though.
My main concerns:
- It uses MySQL MyISAM tables (fast with full-text indexing, but no foreign keys or transactions). I’d really expect InnoDB to be used for a shop.
- URL aliases/mod-rewrites don’t work and there are few SEO considerations – descriptions and keywords can’t be entered. This should be fixed in the next version, but mod-rewrites need easier implementation (there’s currently a lookup table that must be manually populated with the real and aliased URL for every page).
- Template values are inserted using global variables. It feels dirty, and problems could occur with that approach. The current templates use transitional HTML, but I think standards-based versions should be possible.
It’s worth keeping an eye on the project and it’s definitely one I’d consider as it matures.
Magento (v0.6.1360 tested)
A serious amount of effort has gone into Magento. It’s huge, can run multiple shops, and has an Amazon-like plethora of features. The interface is nice, support is excellent, and there’s lots of help including video tutorials. InnoDB tables are used, mod-rewrites work, and SEO is well implemented.
My main concerns:
- It has high system requirements and could get slow with lots of users. The system could benefit from page caching.
- It’s a seriously complex piece of software and has a steep learning curve. It’s one for large companies rather than one-man stores (I couldn’t get a product to appear on the home page!)
- Templating is very flexible and uses XML to define multiple HTML page layouts and sections. But, it’s complicated: there are dozens of files in multiple locations, and the documentation appears to be wrong or out of date. It also seems to embed page-specific JS form validation code in the page head – not great.
Only a few people appear to be using it so far … that’s a little worrying given the positive press it’s had. Magento is very promising, but I would suggest waiting until it’s out of beta before using it.
- categories: all popular, software
- trackback: http://www.optimalworks.net/blog/2007/software/opencart-magento/trackback
- bookmark: del.icio.us, digg, facebook, twitter, reddit, Furl, Spurl, Blinklist, Slashdot, Technorati, Yahoo!
25 comments:
17 November 2007 Daniel Kerr commented
18 November 2007 Craig commented
13 January 2008 Opensourcer commented
13 January 2008 Craig commented
24 January 2008 Israel commented
24 January 2008 Craig commented
5 April 2008 Chuck Miller commented
7 April 2008 Craig commented
28 May 2008 Brad commented
28 May 2008 Craig commented
25 June 2008 Terry commented
26 June 2008 Craig commented
2 September 2008 Matt commented
8 September 2008 inets commented
8 February 2009 Callum Rimmer commented
2 June 2009 Worried commented
2 June 2009 Craig commented
19 June 2009 Basharat commented
19 September 2009 Tony commented
21 October 2009 Justin commented
22 October 2009 OpenCart Hosting, Open Cart Web Hosting, OpenCart eCommerce Web Hosting | Web Hosting Reviews commented
27 November 2009 Scott commented
30 December 2009 Murray price commented
14 January 2010 Charles commented
25 February 2010 Opencart commented